O’Donnell, Weiss & Mattei, P.C.

Misty A. Toothman


Misty A. Toothman is a Chester County native who returned to the area after supporting her husband’s career in the Marine Corps. Misty initially developed her work ethic, resilience, and ingenuity on her family’s dairy farm; she continued to develop those qualities as the spouse of a constantly deploying Marine, homeschooling mother of three children, and advocate for wounded veterans and their families. Misty’s nontraditional path to becoming an attorney has equipped her with a unique perspective and skillset that she applies to her legal practice.

Misty currently lives in a historic stone farmhouse in Berks County, which she and her family have lovingly restored.  While Misty enjoys playing the piano, DIY projects, learning about history, and generally being crafty, most of her time is spent supporting her children’s activities like mountain biking, Scouts BSA, and an ever-growing number of animals including cats, dogs, goats, and chickens.

Client Testimonial:

“The assistance we have received from Misty Toothman, Esquire, in settling an estate this past year has been comprehensive, professional and compassionate.  She and everyone we have encountered at OWM Law have been helpful in making sure everything was taken care of correctly.” -Rose W.

Peer Talk/Review:

“Misty Toothman provides exceptional and dedicated representation to anyone who walks through her door. Not only does she zealously advocate for her clients, her calm and empathetic demeanor offers emotional assistance during difficult times to them and those they care about most. I enthusiastically recommend Misty without reservation.” Liana R. Carvalho Pruna, fellow lawyer in community.

Quote I live by:

“We can’t help everyone, but everyone can help someone.” -Ronald Reagan.


Education & Credentials:

  • Villanova University School of Law, Villanova, Pennsylvania
    • LL.M., Taxation – 2023
  • Villanova University School of Law, Villanova, Pennsylvania
    • J.D. – 2021
  • American Military University
    • Master of Arts – 2012
    • Honors: With High Honors
    • Major: American History
  • Liberty University, Lynchburg, Virginia
    • B.S. – 2003
    • Honors: cum laude
    • Major: Journalism
    • Minor: Psychology
  • Bar Admissions
      • Pennsylvania, 2021

Licenses and Certifications:

  • Title Agent Licensed by the Pennsylvania Insurance Department


(P) 610-323-2800



Professional Associations:

  • Military Spouse JD Network
  • American Bar Association
  • Pennsylvania Bar Association
  • Berks County Bar Association
  • Montgomery County Bar Association
  • Montgomery County Estate Planning Council
  • Chester County Estate Planning Council
  • American Land Title Association, Member

Pro-Bono Activities:

  • Village Library, Morgantown, P.A., Board of Trustees
  • Twin Valley Rotary Club, Member
  • Operation Heal Our Patriots, Key Leader
  • FOB Truth, Board Member
  • Elizabeth Dole Foundation Pennsylvania Fellow, Alumni
  • Operation Homefront, Former Peer Group Facilitator
  • Operation Second Chance, Former Volunteer
  • Joni & Friends Warrior Getaway, Former Peer Group Facilitator
  • Samaritan’s Purse U.S. Disaster Relief, Former Volunteer


Previous slide
Next slide